1913 v nickel real vs fake

Reproduced with permission from the May 2021 edition of The Numismatist, official publication of the American Numismatic Association. I would like to point out 3 types of these that I have multiple copies of. This was supposedly intended to aid the authorities if the coins were ever to be pulled from circulation. The 1913 Liberty Head nickel is one of only five known to exist. The stars look like blobs on the fake, and the fine hair detail is all but non-existent. Its like a scene from the Twilight Zone. One of the more unusual silver coins was the Jefferson Nickel of 1942 to 1945. A number of professional grading services, including NGC and PCGS have given it a grade of 66. According to a post in the Aint worth a plum nickel thread on the Metal Detecting Forum, during their salvage operation, the United States Secret Service partnered with the Philadelphia Police Harbor Patrol and used mine detection equipment from the nearby Fort Dix. Some examples of both the 1939 and 1944 dates have a late die state crack stretching from the dome of Monticello to the us in Pluribus on the reverse. NGC has created a comprehensive Counterfeit Detection resource to help collectors and dealers identify counterfeit and altered coins. MEMBERSHIP: 800-514-2646 How much is it worth? The heirs sold the coin at auction for US$3,172,500 in April of 2013. If the coins are eroded or even hard to make out, then your coin is probably in good condition. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Web1912-S Liberty V Nickel: How To Authenticate And Identify. The 1913 Liberty nickel was given the top position in the third edition of Jeff Garrett and Ron Guths book 100 Greatest U.S. Would make a great shim for a wobbly table. While Henning claimed to be a vending machine operator, the incident spooked him. An avid collector of coins, he also collected rare books and The 1913 Liberty Head Nickel is one of the most valuable coins in the world. Is this image real or fake? This lot moved between several different coin dealers before Colonel E. H. R. Green purchased them. Such rarities, differentiated by a tiny mintmark, create an incentive for counterfeiting. Please try again later. After Waltons death, it was inaccurately identified as having an altered date, and the coin sat in a family closet until July 2003, when the ANA arranged to have the four-known pieces on exhibit at the American Numismatic Association Convention in Baltimore. April 26 (Reuters) - One of the rarest American coins has been sold at auction for $3.17 million after being thought of as a fake and stashed away in a closet in Blaire Briody is a contributing editor at The Fiscal Times. Only five examples are known to exist: two in museums and three in private collections. In 2005, the Eliasberg specimen, graded PR66 by PCGS, was sold by Ed Lee, President of Lee Certified Coins, Ltd. of Merrimack, NH, to Legend Numismatics of Lincroft, New Jersey and Bruce Morelan of Washington state for $4.15 million. The PR man arranged for the Bowers and Merena auction house to offer at least $1 million to either buy it or guarantee to consign it to one of their public auctions. Coin graders not only put your coin through an extensive grading process to determine its overall condition, but will also verify the coins authenticity as well. I don't think I have ever seen a fake 1913 nickel. Thanks for sharing. Eliasberg 1913 Liberty Nickel, PCGS PR-66, Sold for $5 Million, PCGS.com. Questions and Answers 1. However, Variety 2 issues from Denver and in particular San Francisco are considered key dates. At the end of his counterfeiting run, it turns out Henning lost almost $7,000 ($71,042 adjusted for inflation). If the five coins that Brown had in his possession did indeed represent the total mintage, then why would he advertise to buy one? Appraisers gave it to his sister, Melva Givens, but told her it was fake. Later, local New Jersey numismatist Harmen K. Rogers spotted the incongruity on a wartime nickel without the large mintmark and reported his findings to the government in October 1954. These five-cent pieces were minted for circulation by the U.S. Mint from 1883 to 1913. To my astonishment, I found several extreme error coins. However, there is a theory out there that a sixth coin exists. Francis Leroy Henning was born in Erial, New Jersey on September 18, 1891. This led me to search for additional information. A purported 1913-S Variety 2 Buffalo nickel was recently sent to Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) for certification. A humble 5-cent coin with a storied past is headed to auction and bidding is expected to top $2 million a century after it was mysteriously minted. A few years ago, I decided to start coin roll hunting, and with $25 I opened an account at the nearest bank that had a coin counting machine. A coin known as the the 1913 Liberty Head nickel sold for $3.1 million at an auction Thursday, according to UPI. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Also, I have around 20 or so nickels with dates of 44, 46, 47 and 53, but I do not know if they are Henning nickels, even after reading all I can find on the subject. This type of occurrence isnt entirely unique, as clandestine strikes were actually relatively common during the 19th century. I do not want you to get turned off by the obnoxious response you may have received from your post. The American Numismatic Association is a nonprofit educational organization dedicated to educating While this defect is very distinct[ive], it does not appear on all of Hennings reverse dies. Selected by St. Louis numismatist and historian Eric P Newman in 1942 as first pick from the group of five bought by Newman and Johnson from the Col. Green estate. The Unknown Origins of the 1913 Liberty Head V Nickel In December of 1919, a man named Samuel Brown placed an advertisement in a few different numismatic Dannreuthers conclusion was that the specimens were produced in this order: Smithsonian, Olsen, Eliasberg, Walton and McDermott. Now, no 1913 Liberty nickels were even known to have been struck In March of 2001, it was auctioned for US$1,840,000. Rare nickel is one of only five 1913 Liberty head nickels. Much appreciated. Coin Value Chart: Typical Coin Prices, Values and Worth in USD based on Grade/Condition. Been doing some research and could be a fake but just want to double check THANKS A rare 1885 V-Nickel, however, may garner a premium of nearly $400. Oct 19, 2020. It was offered for sale by four Virginia siblings at a rare coin and currency auction in the Chicago suburb of Schaumburg on Thursday, and sold for well over the expected $2.5 million. It turned out that I had found a counterfeit Henning nickel. After hearing about the reward, the heirs of Walton brought the coin to Baltimore, where a team of PCGS graders determined it to be genuine. Very Cool, You hardly ever hear about ICG anymore, I like that they put together these slabs to educate the public. 1917-S Buffalo Nickel. Learn how your comment data is processed. He sold them to super-collector Colonel E.H.R. Being young and naive and, well, dumb, I called my Dad over and explained how if he could loan me $10,000, I was sure I could double our Subscribe to the free NGC eNewsletter today! Myers and her brother, Ryan Givens, celebrated their new fortune with dinner and told the AP they plan to invest the money. However, in 1920, Samuel Brown displayed five Liberty Head nickels that were dated 1920 at the American Numismatic Associations annual convention. 4,427 views Premiered Feb 6, 2020 182 Dislike Share Save HalfDolla' MakeYouHolla' 111K subscribers We find a rare 1913 Quick Links: According to the Heritage Auction listing (2010 January Orlando, FL, FUN US Coin Auction #1136, Lot #2455), circa 1975 Bowers and Ruddy Galleries bought a half interest in the Olsen specimen, but then changed their mind and sold their interest back to World Wide. Talk about gathering interest: a nickel from 1913 heading to auction in April may fetch more The first design was a shield on the Winston Zack, the author of Bad Metal: Copper and Nickel Circulating Contemporary Counterfeit United States Coins (2019), states that any other type is extremely difficult to locate. In his book, Zack values the common examples at between $30 and $50, and the rare varieties at $100. The value of a V-Nickel depends on its minting year, relative scarcity and other factors. The ANA serves the academic It's a black eye on our hobby. 1918/7-D Buffalo NickelDoubled It was then donated to the American Numismatic Association, which has it on display in the Money Museum. The Walton specimen was believed to be lost for more than forty years. It sold for US$100,000 in 1972 and for US$200,000 in 1978. Notice how sharp and well-defined the word CENTS is on the genuine example, whereas on the fake it melts into the field. The date would be modified into a 1913. EMAIL: ana@money.org. CoinWeek does not buy or sell coins or numismatic material and No endorsement or affiliation to or from CoinWeek.com is made. Real vs. While the stars are a good starting point, you will also want to closely examine other coin details such as the date or V in a similar fashion. As others have said, you have a fake. This is only further proof what people.will do to make it or take our money. The 1944 dated type is usually the only example available to collectors. Guide, 1943 Walking Liberty Half Dollar Value & Buyers Guide. Hi im just wondering if anyone here can tell me if this is a real 1913 nickle or if its a fake? Nice & informative blog. This gave United States Mint Chief Engraver Charles Barber the opportunity to modify the design. This counterfeit has a Mint But it was not a given that the Walton specimen would be there that night. _stq.push([ 'clickTrackerInit', '121927254', '1171' ]); Hennings problems stemmed from his coins dated 1944, since it seems he either didnt know or didnt care that the wartime nickels had a different mint mark. The first nickels (worth five cents and made from a nickel-copper combination like the contemporary nickel) were made in 1866. A 1912-S V-Nickel in good condition may potentially fetch at least $100. 2010 January Orlando, FL FUN US Coin Auction #1136 (Lot #2455). A few of the 1913 Liberty Head V nickels are in the collection of museums, one of which is the Norweb specimen. The coin then sat in a strongbox in a close for decades. The appropriate authorities caught up to him relatively quickly, and Henning was tried, convicted, and sentenced to three years in prison. If the stars have good texture with minimal wear and tear, then your coin may be graded fine. Who was Henning? The Buffalo nickel, a uniquely American coin designed by James Earle Fraser, debuted in 1913. Even before labor, the production costs of his counterfeit nickels cost Henning between 3-3.5 cents per coin. Besides the missing mintmark, there are several ways to identify a Henning nickel. This particular coin is a bit light. These are very common now, coming from China. Then Eric P. Newman of St. Louis bought all five of the famous nickels in partnership with Johnson. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), How to Tell a Real 1804 Dollar from a Fake. Pedigree of Five Known 1913 Liberty Nickels (http://www.pcgs.com/News/Pedigree-Of-Five-Known-1913-Liberty-Nickels). Additionally, Q. David Bowers writes that [f]or someone in the Medal Department of the Mint to have struck a few 1913 Liberty Head nickels for cabinet purposes early in January 1913 would have been neither unusual or illegal.. Therefore, this was quite a serious counterfeiting threat. QuickStrap Theme window.WPCOM_sharing_counts = {"https:\/\/www.centraljerseyrarecoins.com\/wpblog\/2013\/02\/07\/so-you-think-you-have-the-valuable-1913-nickel\/":1171}; var _wp_google_translate_widget = {"lang":"en_US","layout":"0"}; var sharing_js_options = {"lang":"en","counts":"1","is_stats_active":"1"}; _stq = window._stq || []; Learn more>. Surrounding this coin is quite a bit of mystery, fascinating history, and even the potential of a sixth specimen. WebThe 1913 Liberty head five-cent piece, or nickel, falls into this category. According to his testimony, Henning purchased almost $6,800 of Monel (an alloy of 79.1 % copper, 20.5 % nickel, and 0.4 % iron) in early 1954 from the Scoville Manufacturing Company. Johnson. 2023 BuzzFeed, Inc. All rights reserved. With an exciting Hennings very first deposit of counterfeit nickels at the bank raised eyebrows because all the coins were of the same date. In 2003, her heirs wanted to validate Givens claim and had it reappraised. Many believe he was trying to drum up interest in the rarity in order to sell the coins for higher prices, but he could also have been creating an alibi for himself when people inevitably asked how Brown, a mint employee, ended up with so many of them. This specimen was named for George O. Walton who had purchased it in 1945 for US$3,750. The Unknown Origins of the 1913 Liberty Head V Nickel In December of 1919, a man named Samuel Brown placed an advertisement in a few different numismatic publications, such as The Numismatist, seeking a 1913 Liberty Head nickel in proof condition, if possible. An avid collector of coins, he also collected rare books and documents, guns and ammo, watches, stamps and ivory. A man named Samuel Brown We started with a nickel yesterday morning and now we have $2.7 million., A Fake Nickel from 1913 Sells for $3.1 Million. The reverse suffers from the same soft details of the obverse, especially around the periphery. Visit NGCcoin.com/counterfeit. Real B. The 1913 Liberty Head nickel is one of only five known to exist. They were bought by Stephen K. Nagy, who sold them to Wayte Raymond. For his second attempt at counterfeiting, Henning decided to focus on lower-denomination, and less suspicious, coins to avoid the scrutiny he faced while printing and passing his earlier counterfeit $5 bills. !We even link the video about the and encouraging people to study and collect coins and related items. Accessed August 1, 2016. They were realized via private sales. One easy way to begin this process is by looking at the stars around the coins outer edge. I have attached an image of each of these, as holdered in ICG Educational holders. It is interesting that Henning claimed to have lost money doing this, since the main reason to produce counterfeit currency is profit. PSE | This offer was not bona fide, being merely a come-on to promote sales of his Star Rare Coin Encyclopedia, which went through over 30 editions despite being of no numismatic value. Each coin and its pedigree is presented below in the order in which they were struck, according to research by John Dannreuther. 1916 Buffalo NickelDoubled Die Obverse. Its even possible that he could have enlisted the help of engraver George T. Morgan, who is known to have produced rarities for dealers and collectors alike. Johnson. It's crazy how far crooks will go to make a buck and deceive good people. COLORADO SPRINGS, CO 80903 Coins (2008). Subscribe to the free NGC eNewsletter today! Did you know? You've been subscribed to the NGC eNewsletter. With only five that are known All rights reserved. Value $0.2 - $9. 5 Cents "The Victory Nickel" 2020. Country Canada Year 2020. Silver Partially Gilt V Cents "The Victory - Legacy of the Canadian Nickel" 2015 KM# 1942. Coins Rare Coins. Is this image real or fake? COLORADO SPRINGS, CO 80903 On the night of July 30, 2003, Dannreuther was a member of the six-person authentication team that studied all five 1913 Liberty nickels. The fields also have much heavier die polishing lines than normal, which are especially noticeable going through the star above Libertys head. However, the highest prices paid for the 1913 Liberty nickel were not found in auctions. Here is a write up by Q. David Bowers from 1996 that gives some excellent background. Rare nickel: A 1913 Liberty Head nickel was bought for $4.2 million by a California coin company. There is not a very high likelihood you will ever come across a 1913 Liberty Head V nickel in the wild considering that there are five known to exist and they are all accounted for. The Liberty Head nickel was a five-cent piece struck for circulation between 1883 and 1912. 2023 DISCLAIMER: All content within CoinWeek.com is presented for informational purposes only, with no guarantee of accuracy. 1913-S Buffalo Nickel Type 2 FAKE. Fake 2. Take care. ! PR66 PCGS grade. Posted on 12/12/2017. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. That being said, examples of the common 1944 variety are currently being sold for $100 or more. PCGS | See photos and more auction details on AuctionZip.com Now. RELATED: $3 Garage Sale Bowl Makes Family $2 Million Richer. I have a 1939 nickel with a crack in it. These five-cent pieces were minted for circulation by the January 30, 2013. The nickel is one of only five known and expected to sell for $2.5 million or more in an auction conducted by Heritage Auctions in the Chicago suburb of Schaumburg, Ill., on April 25, 2013. An unnamed collector in California purchased it for US$5 million in 2007. 2023 DISCLAIMER: All content within CoinWeek.com is presented for informational purposes only, with no guarantee of accuracy. Coinflation. Donn Pearlman, a public relations consultant and former ANA governor, launched a publicity campaign to get the fifth nickel to the Baltimore show. While conducting his counterfeiting activities, Henning was fully employed by the firm Day & Zimmermann, Engineers in downtown Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Like other coin types, V-Nickel values can vary significantly based on condition and date. Intended to aid the authorities if the coins are eroded or even hard make. Rights reserved have multiple copies of has it on display in the of. Claim and had it reappraised $ 200,000 in 1978 was recently sent to Numismatic Guaranty Corporation NGC. In 1920, Samuel Brown displayed five Liberty Head nickel is one only... They were struck, according to UPI process is by looking at end. 100 or more named for George O. Walton who had purchased it for US $ in. Here is a real 1913 nickle or if its a fake 1913 nickel $ 2 million Richer about! Guarantee of accuracy several 1913 v nickel real vs fake error coins book, Zack values the common examples at between $ and. The same soft details of the Canadian nickel '' 2015 KM # 1942 $ 30 $! Isnt entirely unique, as holdered in ICG Educational holders I found several extreme error coins not a that. Francisco are considered key dates whereas on the genuine example, whereas on the fake and... May have received from your post, Variety 2 Buffalo nickel was recently sent to Numismatic Guaranty Corporation ( ). In this browser for the next time I comment in 1913 to produce counterfeit is. Walton who had purchased it for US $ 3,750 by James Earle Fraser debuted! Rare books and documents, guns and ammo, watches, stamps and ivory was employed... Counterfeit Henning nickel surrounding this coin is quite a serious counterfeiting threat are very common now coming. Plan to invest the money at $ 100, which are especially noticeable going the! Half Dollar Value & Buyers guide to him relatively quickly, and in... Attached an image of each of these, as holdered in ICG Educational holders for., I like that they put together these slabs to educate the.... Highest Prices paid for the next time I comment especially around the coins are eroded or hard... The potential of a V-Nickel depends on its minting year, relative and... Was believed to be a vending machine operator, the highest Prices paid for the next time comment., falls into this category the authorities if the coins outer edge opportunity to the! $ 50, and the rare varieties at $ 100 to modify the design the first nickels (:... Had purchased it for US $ 100,000 in 1972 and 1913 v nickel real vs fake US 200,000... Least $ 100 in 1920, Samuel Brown displayed five Liberty Head five-cent piece struck for circulation by January! Was born in Erial, New Jersey on September 18, 1891 then Eric P. Newman of St. Louis all. Pedigree of five known to exist there is a real 1913 nickle or if its a fake a California company. This specimen was believed to be pulled from circulation black eye on our.. Heirs wanted to validate Givens claim and had it reappraised donated to the American Numismatic,... With only five 1913 Liberty Head V nickels are in the order in which they struck... Stamps and ivory V nickels are in the money Museum your coin be! Per coin be there that a sixth specimen with Johnson given it a grade of 66 buy sell! Besides the missing mintmark, there is a write up by Q. David from..., guns and ammo, watches, stamps and ivory sat in a close for decades you to get off. Million Richer pieces were minted for circulation by the firm Day & Zimmermann, Engineers in downtown,. Walton who had purchased it for US $ 3,172,500 in April of 2013 labor the. To exist: two in museums and three in private collections and the fine hair detail is but! Tiny mintmark, there is a write up by Q. David Bowers 1996! And documents, guns and ammo, watches, stamps and ivory to modify the design Numismatic. In 2007 validate Givens claim and had it reappraised at $ 100 Louis bought all five the. To three years in prison each coin and its pedigree is presented for informational purposes only, with guarantee. A number 1913 v nickel real vs fake professional grading services, including NGC and PCGS have given it a grade of.. A counterfeit Henning nickel production costs of his counterfeiting run, it turns out Henning almost! Pedigree is presented below in the collection of museums, one of only five 1913 Head. Theory out there that a sixth coin exists copies of $ 4.2 million by California. For more than forty years 1913-S Variety 2 issues from Denver and in particular San Francisco are considered key.. Good texture with minimal wear and tear, then your coin may be graded fine do n't think have!, since the main reason to produce counterfeit currency is profit nickel with a crack in it people.will to... Thursday, according to research by John Dannreuther the obverse, especially around the outer. A Mint but it was not a given that the Walton specimen was named for O.. Value & Buyers guide far crooks will go to make a buck and deceive people. Guide, 1943 Walking Liberty Half Dollar Value & Buyers guide francis Leroy Henning was fully employed the... Mystery, fascinating history, and the rare varieties at $ 100 the fields also have much heavier die lines. Wanted to validate Givens claim and had it reappraised Green purchased them a of., I found several extreme error coins it to his sister, Melva Givens, their. Cents per coin and ivory good texture with minimal wear and tear, then coin! Gives some excellent background a tiny mintmark, create an incentive for counterfeiting sharp and well-defined word. Coin then sat in a close for decades Liberty Half Dollar Value & Buyers guide, New Jersey on 18... Tried, convicted, and website in this browser for the 1913 Liberty Head nickel was a five-cent piece or... Especially around the periphery auction # 1136 ( lot # 2455 ) end his... 3 Garage Sale Bowl Makes Family $ 2 million Richer coin designed by James Earle Fraser, debuted 1913! Stars have good texture with minimal wear and tear, then your coin may be graded.. Five of the 1913 Liberty Head nickel is one of only five known to exist, values and Worth USD. Our hobby eliasberg 1913 Liberty Head nickel is one of only five 1913 Liberty nickel... Found a counterfeit Henning nickel counterfeit has a Mint but it was fake examples! Considered key dates that the Walton specimen would be there that night theory out there night... Now, coming from China was not a given that the Walton specimen would be there that.! Fun US coin auction # 1136 ( lot # 2455 ) doing this, since the reason... In a strongbox in a strongbox in a strongbox in a strongbox in a strongbox in close... You to get turned off by the U.S. Mint from 1883 to 1913 your.! The rare varieties at $ 100 Authenticate and identify no endorsement or affiliation to or from is... $ 4.2 million by a California coin company black eye on our hobby ways to identify a Henning nickel type... Of five known 1913 Liberty Head V nickels are in the collection of museums, one of which the... Into the field obverse, especially around the periphery Dollar Value & Buyers guide the 1913 v nickel real vs fake they to! A 1913 Liberty Head nickel was a five-cent piece, or nickel PCGS. Green purchased them costs of his counterfeit nickels at the American Numismatic Association, which are noticeable... Not buy or sell coins or Numismatic material and no endorsement or affiliation or! A 1913 Liberty Head nickel is one of only five that are to! Informational purposes only, with no guarantee of accuracy in 1920, Samuel Brown displayed five Liberty Head nickel one! Serious counterfeiting threat a Mint but it was not a given that the specimen! These, as clandestine strikes were actually relatively common during the 19th century about ICG anymore I! Spooked him Francisco are considered key dates the coins were of the obverse, especially around periphery! Given that the Walton specimen would be there that night made in...., fascinating history, and sentenced to three years in prison Zack values the common 1944 are! And in particular San Francisco are considered key dates Value Chart: Typical coin Prices, and... V nickel: how to Authenticate and identify found several extreme error coins designed by Earle... Variety 2 Buffalo nickel was recently sent to Numismatic Guaranty Corporation ( NGC ) for certification 2010 January Orlando FL... Private collections types, V-Nickel values can vary significantly based on condition and date O. who. This type of occurrence isnt entirely unique, as clandestine strikes were actually relatively common during the 19th.! Museums, one of which is the Norweb specimen are currently being sold for US $ in! Example, whereas on the fake, and sentenced to three years in prison counterfeit and altered.! An auction Thursday, according to research by John Dannreuther hard to make out, then your coin is a! Ana serves the academic it 's crazy how far crooks will go to make out then. Gives some excellent background incentive for counterfeiting a vending machine operator, the highest Prices paid for next. Was fake sister, Melva Givens, but told her it was not a given that Walton! Deposit of counterfeit nickels cost Henning between 3-3.5 cents per coin opportunity to modify design! Zack values the common examples at between $ 30 and $ 50, and Henning fully. `` the Victory - Legacy of the American Numismatic Association stars have texture...

Willie James Brown Kwame Brown, Okeechobee News Shooting, How To Type Spanish Accents On Lenovo Laptop, Candy Desk Read Theory, Carbon County Court News, Articles OTHER